← All items

Element Organisation in progress

COMETA

Private French association of former defence officials, engineers and scientists; active 1996-c.2006

Wrote the 1999 report 'UFOs and Defense: What Should We Prepare For?', which judged the extraterrestrial hypothesis the most probable explanation for some cases and recommended defence preparedness and international cooperation; its English edition was handed to NASA in 2001.

Full name
Comité d'Études Approfondies
Also known as
Committee for In-Depth Studies
Location
Paris, France
Coordinates
48.856600, 2.352200
UAP Research Map ↗

Research

Summary

COMETA (Comité d'Études Approfondies) was a private French committee, mostly auditors of the Institut des hautes études de défense nationale (IHEDN), that studied UFOs from a national-defence perspective and published the COMETA report in July 1999.

Key facts

  • 1995: Gen. Denis Letty proposes the committee to Gen. Bernard Norlain (then IHEDN director); work begins informally in 1996 with support of the IHEDN auditors' association.
  • 24 February 1999: registered as a non-profit association under the 1901 law.
  • Members included Gen. Bruno Lemoine, Adm. Marc Merlo, Michel Algrin, Gen. Pierre Bescond, Denis Blancher, Christian Marchal (ONERA) and Gen. Alain Orszag; contributors included Jean-Jacques Velasco (SEPRA/CNES) and Gen. Joseph Domange.
  • 16 July 1999: the report appears in a special issue of the magazine VSD; it had been sent beforehand to President Jacques Chirac and Prime Minister Lionel Jospin.
  • c.2006: the association becomes dormant.

UAP relevance

The report's senior authors made it one of the most cited 'official-sounding' UFO studies; English translations circulated in the US, including via Leslie Kean's 2000 articles and the Rosin-Cypher hand-over to NASA in 2001.

Claims and controversy

  • It was not commissioned by the French government; IHEDN distanced itself and the government made no official response (Jospin's chief of staff reportedly annotated it 'to mark his interest'). Sceptics questioned its credibility and its section on US 'disinformation'.

Sources 3

  1. COMETA report
    2trust 2 of 5Wikipedia (encyclopedia wiki)
    • Wikipedia: Encyclopedia wiki (baseline for this type)2.0
    • Result2.0
    Reference Wikipedia
    Wikipedia article on COMETA report. Wikipedia overview article, continuously edited; good for orientation and its references, but a secondary source to verify against primaries.
    Registration 24 Feb 1999, members, reception, dormancy c.2006.
  2. The COMETA report
    2trust 2 of 5Patrick Gross (ufology / ufologie) (uap website)
    • Patrick Gross (ufology / ufologie): Uap website (baseline for this type)2.0
    • Result2.0
    Blog Patrick Gross (ufologie.patrickgross.org)
    Detailed English summary of the report.
    Membership list, 16 July 1999 publication, sent to Chirac and Jospin.
  3. COMETA (RationalWiki)
    2trust 2 of 5EncycloReader (RationalWiki) (encyclopedia wiki)
    • EncycloReader (RationalWiki): Encyclopedia wiki (baseline for this type)2.0
    • Result2.0
    Reference RationalWiki via EncycloReader
    Sceptical wiki; seen in search results only.
    Not solicited by the French government; IHEDN disassociated itself.